Tax Court Rejects Transferee Liability Claim

In Swords Trust v. Comm’r., 142 T.C. No. 19, the IRS attempted to bypass state law and use federal law to assert transferee liability against four trusts that each owned an interest in Davreyn Corp. At its most basic, Davreyn Corp. through a series of transactions sold stock to a personal holding company which in turn sold shares of a publicly traded company. The IRS disallowed the transactions and then attempted to recharacterize the sale as a sale by the Trusts under the federal substance over form doctrine.

IRC § 6901(a) provides that the IRS may proceed against a transferee of property to assess and collect tax, penalties and interest owed by the transferor. It is not an imposition of liability against the transferee but an authorization to pursue the transferee under applicable state law. In Swords, the IRS attempted to circumvent state law and apply a federal substance over form doctrine to avoid Virginia law, which did not support a finding of transferee liability.

Judge Marvel rejected the IRS’ argument and sided with multiple Courts of Appeal. She went on to distinguish the Tax Court’s previous inexplicable holding in Feldman v. Comm’r., TC Memo 2011-297. In Feldman, the Tax Court applied federal law first under a bizarre equity argument and then applied state law to find the transferee liable. Thankfully, the Tax Court did not expand Feldman, but it also did not reject it.

We’ve handled numerous large transferee liability cases. Should you have a similar situation please give us a call.

Practice Areas

Practice Areas

Wagner, Johnston and Rosenthal P.C. provides a range of legal services in the following areas:

  • Commercial Leasing
  • Commercial Litigation
  • Commercial Real Estate Law
  • Corporate & Finance Law
  • Corporate Governance
  • Employment Law
  • Franchise & Business Opportunity Law
  • Heathcare IT
  • International Business
  • Mergers & Acquisitions
  • Private Equity & Venture Capital
  • Sports Law
  • Technology Law
  • Other Areas of Practice

Click on a topic to the left to learn more.

Our Attorneys


Our attorneys provide the most comprehensive legal service around. If you are an entrepreneur or small business in a bind, let us assist you. We pride ourselves in providing excellent service to our clients in a range of legal areas. With decades of experience in areas of practice from commercial law to health care and taxation, Wagner, Johnston and Rosenthal P.C. can help. Click on a name to the left to learn more about each attorney and their specialties.

Our Clients


Wagner, Johnston & Rosenthal represents a broad range of privately held businesses, executives and entrepreneurs. While a majority of the Firm’s clientele is based in the greater Atlanta area, the Firm also services clients located throughout the United States as well as in foreign countries.

The industries the Firm represents are as diverse as the economy: manufacturers and service industries, real estate developers, financial concerns, lending institutions, health care professionals and facilities, benefit consultants, software and technology developers, public service agencies, investment partnerships, travel agencies, private schools, engineering concerns, leasing companies, telecommunications concerns, hotel developers, franchisors and professional sports teams.